CPU utilization Dave Welch EBS ESXi servers Exadata Exalogic Exalytics Forbes Hyper-V IDC IOUG Larry Ellison Oracle Oracle 10g Oracle Cloud Oracle Cloud Infrastructure Oracle Cloud VMware Solution (OCVS) Oracle Enterprise Linux Oracle Open World Oracle RAC Oracle Virtual Machine OVM Sun Tzu Tech TechTarget Virtual Machines vMotion VMware VMware Cloud VMware Cloud Foundation VMware Cloud on AWS VMware vCloud Air Wim Coekaerts

Oracle and VMware Announce Oracle Cloud VMware Solution

Oracle and VMware Announce Oracle Cloud VMware Solution

Oracle and VMware Announce Oracle Cloud VMware Answer

posted September 16, 2019, 9:03 PM by

Dave Welch (@OraVBCA), CTO & Chief Evangelist

Right now at Oracle Open World, Larry Ellison announced what a simulcast VMware blog calls Oracle Cloud VMware Answer (OCVS). I’m considering Larry announced OVM’s deprecation. But we’ll get to that later. Right here’s what Larry stated in less than a minute and a half utilizing a single slide:

“We’ve received an in depth partnership with VMware per the settlement we simply signed, we’re the only cloud that may lets you manage your personal VMware stack. What I imply by that is in case your VMware stack that you simply’re operating on-prem proper now, you’ll be able to carry and shift it intact to the Oracle cloud. You should use your present instruments, your present operational procedures. Or you’ll be able to take your on-prem VMware surroundings and hyperlink it as much as OCI. We let you really control model management, operations, improve time of the VMware stack, making it straightforward, enabling you emigrate, if that’s what you need to do, it lets you migrate from on-prem into the cloud with virtually no change—nearly no change. A really huge deal. An important announcement…”

Listed here are selective quotes from VMware Company’s simulcast announcement:

The centerpiece of this relationship is a new service that can be provided by Oracle referred to as Oracle Cloud VMware Answer…

Oracle and VMware have entered into a brand new mutual help settlement for presently supported Oracle products operating on VMware environments.

Quote from the mutual help agreement:  “Oracle shall, using affordable efforts, help Oracle clients with lively help contracts operating supported variations of Oracle merchandise in Oracle supported computing environments who encounter issues when operating these merchandise on VMware virtualized environments.”

Underneath this new partnership, clients will be capable of help their hybrid cloud strategies by operating VMware Cloud Foundation on Oracle Cloud Infrastructure
.…
As part of this partnership, Oracle will even provide technical help for Oracle software program operating in VMware environments each in customer on-premise knowledge facilities and Oracle-certified cloud environments
.…
“VMware is delighted that for the first time, Oracle will officially supply technical help for Oracle merchandise operating on VMware. This can be a win-win for patrons,” stated Sanjay Poonen, chief working officer, buyer operations, VMware
.…
Oracle will provide administrative access to the underlying physical servers, enabling a degree of management beforehand solely attainable on premise, and clients will be capable of use VMware vCenter to handle both their on-premise clusters and Oracle Cloud-based SDDCs via a single pane of glass. Oracle may also present first line technical help for this answer.

Years ago, VMware approached AWS after VMware’s vCloud Air was significantly lagging out there. Comparing Oracle Cloud Infrastructure’s market share appears even more dichotomous.

Why would Oracle even be excited about such a partnership? In any case, they’ve Oracle Digital Machine. (Chuckle.) But once more, I’ll hold my OVM eulogy until I cowl other issues.

What the Announcement Is

Discover VMware’s quoting of the Oracle/VMware settlement by which all Oracle merchandise might be supported in customer on-premise clusters and Oracle Licensed Cloud environments.

  • Although not an settlement between Oracle and Oracle clients, this Oracle/VMware settlement quote is a breath of recent air in comparison with MyOracleSupport word 249212.1. In my remark, that word has actually simply been an Oracle Sales sledge hammer to daunt clients from adopting VMware. The help observe at present says when you’re operating on VMware and encounter a problem not in Oracle’s information base, you’ll be compelled to replatform to reveal metallic to show the issue. In all our years of architecting and supporting enterprise crucial Oracle workloads on VMware, we’ve solely ever heard of 1 customer that needed to replatform for diagnostics functions. It seems to me that the Oracle/VMware agreement would necessitate Oracle’s amending of 249212.1.
  • Oracle has declined to help Oracle Actual Software Clusters (RAC) operating in any cloud aside from their own. Will Oracle deem AWS a “Certified Cloud surroundings”? Will extra of the agreement be released which will clarify this situation? I will amend this submit if and when more info turns into out there.

What the Announcement is Not

This is not VMware Cloud on AWS or Dell/EMC, at the least not but. The announcement is VMware Cloud Basis operating on Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI). There’s an enormous difference.

Nothing in the announcement modifications Oracle’s Oracle on VMware licensing policy, which has no benefit in the contract.

During their buyers’ name last week, Oracle’s leadership stated (and/or implied) time and again that in case your cloud answer doesn’t include 100% tooling from the same vendor, it’s illegitimate or no less than not nearly as good. (Cough.)

Will we see VMware-enabled Exadata, Exalogic, and Exalytics? On the one hand, Oracle Company speakers at IOUG the yr Oracle announced the OVM choice on Exadata advised not utilizing it until you actually needed it. I might assume Ellison decided to move ahead with this VMware alliance as it promotes the all-important-to-Oracle Cloud. The final place I’d need my financially-optimizing VMware tooling can be on the typically CPU-bloated, and subsequently financially de-optimized, Exa hardware.

The Securities Class Grievance and Metropolis of Windfall lawsuit allege Cloud credits have been DOA—85-90% of these “clients” had no intention of utilizing them in any respect, let alone renewing them. Will Oracle permit Oracle Cloud “clients” that received SaaS credit (as opposed to OCI credit) the privilege of changing those credits to OCVS? Larry was having a great time at this time self-congratulating on Oracle’s generosity. We’ll see how far that generosity extends.

How lengthy will this Oracle/VMware relationship last? The truth that Oracle and VMware have a contract might not imply that the celebration that sells the product has to continue to sell it. There have been a number of affiliations via the years that have worked no less than for a time period, regardless that Oracle didn’t personal the whole stack. I’m reminded of the IBM RS/6000 relationship of the early ‘90’s. Nevertheless, I’m additionally reminded of the Oracle/HP relationship where they have been each on stage and Ellison stated in so many words, “This is the relationship.” A yr later when Ellison acted on the itch to get into the hardware enterprise, he booted HP to the curb so quick their heads have been spinning.

Now VMware’s identify is related to OCI’s operational popularity. It gained’t be long earlier than we’ve a substantial pattern of buyer feedback on OCI’s operations. I might be quite glad to study that the OCI setting’s former dangerous rap is not merited.

Before anybody rushes into OCVS nevertheless, have a very good take a look at the Oracle Cloud Settlement’s prohibition towards probing for safety testing. Should you can’t probe, you haven’t any safety. If the contractual prohibition towards probing doesn’t change with this announcement, I’m afraid I nonetheless can’t advocate it.

OVM Eulogy

It’s been an fascinating journey getting so far.

December 2004 introduced the first settlement between Oracle and VMware Company, from which the excerpt under was taken.

Oracle Server Technologies improvement teams plan to standardize on VMware virtual infrastructure as part of the usual Linux and Windows x86 improvement, check and help surroundings for Oracle Database 10g, Oracle Software Server 10g, Oracle Enterprise Supervisor 10g, and Oracle Collaboration Suite 10g.

With greater than 7,000 VMware virtual machines proposed for inner deployment, Oracle Server Technologies division plans to make use of VMware virtual infrastructure as a normal virtualized improvement platform for its database merchandise.

Two and a half years later (Spring 2007), two mild-mannered full time Oracle employee ESX directors submitted their abstract for VMworld 2007.

Then July 2007 hit and the Oracle/VMware relationship got here aside. It was palpable. For years the summer time 2007 Oracle Magazine arduous copy sat on Home of Brick Principal Architect Jeff Klemme’s desk. The article had a four-page Oracle RAC on VMware cookbook in it that mysteriously disappeared from the web edition. Oracle began misrepresenting the contract to Oracle on VMware clients (you already know the message). In accordance with Oracle, VMware environments had to be licensed prospectively based mostly on the potential of shifting VMs anyplace inside a cluster (at the time, vMotion was restricted to servers inside a cluster).

Regardless of the precise interaction, or occasion, which will have triggered Oracle’s chill towards VMware, it’s painfully apparent that Oracle woke as much as the fact that VMware’s CPU utilization optimization induced an enormous hemorrhage in Oracle’s core know-how license income. Oracle had to have its own hypervisor.

Fall 2007: the two Oracle worker ESX administrators introduced their VMworld paper. Oracle’s fiscal 2007 noticed 14,200 downloads by Oracle’s worldwide gross sales group of 120 VMware Workstation VMs from 34 ESX servers that the speakers had underneath administration at the time the deck was finalized. The server rely had grown to 40 before VMworld hit. Oracle came upon concerning the session and asked VMware to delete the session’s deck and audio.

November 11, 2007: House of Brick pre-announced OVM in our Bricks publication based mostly on an Oracle supervisor’s disclosure to a army commerce rag. Personally, I was really hoping that Oracle would step up and compete with VMware technically and financially, however it never happened. You’ll be able to’t provide financial competition for those who don’t present technical competition.

November 13, 2007 (Wednesday): Larry introduced Oracle Virtual Machine during his keynote. Then he sent his advertising staff scrambling when he introduced his virtual machine was 3 times more performant. The following day Oracle advertising clarified that claim as referring to overhead. Larry stated he would have proven comparison performance numbers, however contract NDA prohibited him from doing so. (VMware stated he never asked.) Ellison also indicated that Oracle would offer a cookbook so individuals might do their very own bakeoffs. It was about six months later when TechTarget referred to as Oracle out for not providing the long-awaited cookbook. Oracle never offered it… in fact.

Meanwhile, OVM languished. Years after OVM’s GA launch, IDC tried to tug collectively a statistical evaluation of the OVM install base however couldn’t get a statistically vital pattern. So, they punted to revered trade publication TechTarget, who did a survey of 300 Oracle clients. The outcome: about 1% have been operating anything on OVM in production. That was no surprise given the issues OVM clients have been having.

I discovered respect for Wim Coekaerts’ Oracle Enterprise Linux/Oracle Digital Machine staff in my interactions as early as 2003. I’ve all the time refused to consider his group couldn’t stabilize its hypervisor (derived from Open Source Xen) until the group had some incentive not to do so. But Home of Brick was encountering substantial, predictable OVM instability years into its GA launch (as we talked about in our weblog posts right here and here). I recall one unhappy, however oh so typical, name from a scaled group operating OVM 3.1.2 asking if we might give them any assurance that Oracle would release a secure OVM within the foreseeable future. They have been uninterested in having their heads taken off by the enterprise models, and had blown properly by means of all of their uptime SLAs. Our CEO, Nathan Biggs, hit me with a needed perspective three years ago: “Dave, hasn’t it occurred to you that Oracle doesn’t want OVM to be secure? If OVM have been secure, it might induce the identical workload optimization and hemorrhage of Oracle processor metric income that VMware induces.” In fact.

Two or three years ago: The second agreement between Oracle and VMware Corporation was introduced – a fuller Oracle on VMware help assertion limited to a niche E-Enterprise Suite module.

So, at present’s Oracle Cloud VMware Answer announcement is Oracle and VMware’s third settlement.

And with at present’s announcement, I’m considering OVM’s dying knell simply rang. Nicely, really OVM was gone already. Truly, it was by no means there. From my vantage point, Oracle’s accomplishments in 13 years with OVM appears to be restricted to:

  • Competing with VMware and Hyper-V in the trade magazines.
  • Discouraging VMware and Hyper-V implementations by “certifying” off of OVM (no matter meaning).

Some Recommendation for VMware

Quoting a 2012 Forbes article: “It’s not too typically that Solar Tzu, the sensible Chinese army strategist and Al Pacino of “The Godfather” give the identical sensible enterprise advice: Hold your mates shut and your enemies closer.” I predict Oracle Cloud VMware Answer can be an fascinating experience for VMware, let alone OCVS clients.